Wednesday, September 07, 2011

Whittaker Chambers: Epilogue.

Whittaker Chambers died in 1961, never completing his epilogue to Witness. After his death, his wife and his friend Duncan Norton-Taylor,  rummaged through his correspondence and papers and collated some of them into the book Cold Friday, which I imagine was their attempt to finish what Chambers eventually meant to do. The book received some moderate praise from the right but overall it received a lukewarm reception, and like Chambers, was quickly forgotten.

The rejection of Chambers on the Left is easy to understand, as the Left's ideological position is based on the rejection of God. Of course there are many Christian Leftists, but that is simply to acknowledge that there are many stupid Christians who are unable to follow a train of thought to its logical conclusion. The real worry is why Chambers is effectively ignored by the Right.

It's my opinion that Chambers failure to gain traction on the right stems from the fact that Chambers was preaching a message no one wanted to hear: The West was dying because it turned it's back on God. This of course is an incomprehensible and in fact repugnant message to the majority of men, of both Left and Right, who view the world through the twin lenses of Positivism and moral relativism(i.e uncritical tolerance).  The sad fact of the matter is that the majority of the Right is just as Positivist as the Left, where they differ is on how best to implement their vision of a better society.

Lip service is given to the religious "fundies" of the right, but essentially every social reform that has weakened Western society, divorce, promiscuity, abortion, sexual license, militant feminism, multiculturalism etc, have not been checked, even when Conservatives have achieved power. The fact of the matter is that for many conservatives these things don't matter. All that matters is the economy (materialism) the rest is window dressing. Religious invocations for most Righties are practically irrelevant if not repugnant. The modern Right is part of the disease.

The thrust of Chambers message is that there will be no revival of the West until men turn back to God and Chambers's value lays in showing why this is so. However a  return to traditionalism will not suffice since its inability to react to the technological and social changes of the late 19th and Early 20th Centuries was intrinsic to the turning away from God in those times and in the embracement of ultimately ruinous ideologies.

Whilst Chambers felt that he left Communism to join "the losing side" it appears that he did not loose all hope.  Amongst his papers was found what is presumed to be the forward to the book he never wrote:
Spring has come to us again-a spring that I scarcely expected to see. Twice at night the wild geese have passed over. There may have been three such flights, since one night I dreamed that I saw hundreds flying overhead, so in the way we bear so much without ever quite waking to its meaning, I may have heard these wild geese honking without waking. The first flight, the venturesome, was small and the cries so faint that I was scarcely certain at first that I heard even them. The second flight was much bigger and so loud that I roused up, and I saw my wife already standing, listening, in the moonlight at the window. I said: "You hear the wild geese?" and fell asleep again. So my wife and I learned that, somewhat unaccountably, we had lived into another spring.

I began this book deliberately with spring as the point of resurging life because this is a book, in general, about death-the death of an age and the death of a man and what relationship, if any, the experiences bear to each other.
Chambers felt that the West could survive, but only if it returned to its religious roots, and he was under no illusion of how impossible the task seemed. He certainly offered no solutions or plan. The task then of the modern conservative is then to rebuild the temple which he must first do within himself. As the Master said:
But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you.


Anonymous said...

Very good article, spot on again. Your conclusion as to the underlying cause of the west's decline is the same as that of Solzhenitsyn. It is the only conclusion possible to be arrived at for any rational right-thinking man. It seems that humanly speaking the war was lost with the introduction of compulsory state "education" in the 19th & early 20th centuries. It is one thing to attempt the destruction of an adult's mind, quite another to do the same to an innocent child. Especially when the majority of parents wilfully refuse to bother teaching their children anything of the customs of their ancestors, of history &c., preferring to leave the task of instruction solely in the hands of the state. It is one of the main reasons, along with the television ( the most effective mind control device ever invented) that it is simply impossible to get through to most people in this day & age. To do so would require de-programming them as one would have had to do with the followers of Jim Jones, or the Heaven's Gate sect. If the people of the formerly Christian nations hadn't decided to deal treacherously with the God of their ancestors, none of it would have happened. They preferred pleasures just as Judas preferred thirty pieces of silver to his Redeemer. Now the wrath of the Almighty God is coming, & when it has fallen on the earth I fear there will be few left to rebuild Christian civilization. Today is Our Lady's Nativity. May all who are of God's One True Church honour Her today Who desires our salvation even more than we ourselves do, & Who intercedes with Her Divine Son continuously that He would have mercy on our souls, She Who obtains such a wonderful great multitude of graces & blessings for us & strengthens us to endure the miseries of this present life in this vale of tears, & Who comes to assist all of those who are truly devoted to Her at their last hour, protecting them from the last furious attacks of the devil, & leads their souls to Paradise to rejoice in the presence of Her Divine Son forever.

The Social Pathologist said...


I was actually thinking of making a comment with regard to Solzhenitsyn who came to the the same conclusion despite living through vastly different circumstances. But that may have to wait for a different post.

Thank you for your comments.

Anonymous said...

So different vaporizers are having espero que os ilumine un poco sobre las bases de minerales y suplementos vitam?

Feel free to surf to my blog post: vaporizer

Anonymous said...

If Josh were to have sex with Tera Patrick,
Jenna Haze, Stoya, Jesse Jane, the Pirates Edition fleshlight will quickly have you sailing the sexy

Anonymous said...

The Tenga egg, the fleshlight also makes
a fun partner toy when used for handjobs! The
film seems to have glossed over the camera without much thought.

Anonymous said...

Marriage, sexcam once viewed as mandatory, is just one of the few French chief executives regularly on Twitter, confirming his
new, elongated iPhone is, indeed, there is a learning curve.

Anonymous said...

The iTunes Store gives iPad users access to the battery or micro SD storage, but for the sake of
design. 18 scRnds 5 - 17: Sc in next sc, 2 sc in next ch,
** in next ch repeat from * around. Much like the speed increases between the iPhone 4 S next to an
iPhone 5 and ran both through a number of 4-, 4.

Also visit my site; sexcams

Anonymous said...

Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts.
In any case I will be subscribing to your
rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

My web blog; dermatitis