Saturday, July 18, 2009

Talking Past Each Other.

Recently I was engaged in a an interesting discussion over at Clio's blog. Namely, has the definition of rape changed? The discussion was basically a continuation of two previous discussions; one from Roissy's and one from the 2Blowhards site. Link 1 and Link 2.

Basically my assertions were that:
1) That in cases of rape, there is a degree of legal and social prejudice which renders the presumption of innocence ineffective.
2)Women interpret things differently to men.

It's on this second point that I wish to concentrate since the discussion itself turned out to be a fascinating example of my second point.

It is my belief, that men and women process information differently and this in turn affects the way that the they interpret events. Male/female misunderstanding is a common enough experience which seems to confirm my belief, but where this misunderstanding can lead to potentially tragic outcomes is in the area of human sexual relations, where frequently consent is not explicitly given but implied

Now in normal human intimacy, sexual escalation does not usually proceed through negotiation, the partner does not explicitly ask if he can kiss the woman, he proceeds and then waits for her response. If the man initiates actions which the woman finds agreeable, the combination of non-resistance, moans, etc. is enough to imply consent. The point here is that the escalation of human intimacy usually occurs through implicit rather than explicit communication.

Now the point of all this is that men are frequently terrible at understanding implicit meaning. A girl may be quite friendly to a man and having only friendly intentions while the same man may think the girl's actions are an attempt to initiate a relationship. This of course may cause offence to the girl and embarrassment to the man without any malice actually being present. For example a man my wish to complement a woman but she may interpret it as a form of harassment, once again without any malice being present.

Communication between parties can be though of as occuring in a first and second order manner. First order communication is unambigous transfer of information without implicit meaning. Implicit communication is what I would term as second order communication, perception is dependent on both the mental make up of the perceiver and the message. So for example a woman who is a militant feminist may interpret a complement as sexual harassment another woman who is not, won't. The point here is that the signal has a different effect depending on the "software/culture" of the receiver.

When Viagra first came on the market, I was surprised at the number of women who would not let their husbands take it or got angry when their husbands did. Initially, I interpreted this as the woman not wanting to be sexually bothered by the man. Until one day I was having a discussion with a lady who was unhappy about her husband using Viagra and I asked her why. "I should be able to get it up for him without him needing medicine". Upon further questioning it became apparent that this woman was unhappy about her husbands Viagra use because it confirmed her self-perceptions of unattractiveness. The husband, whom I knew well, thought his wife was gorgeous and he felt that his wife--whom he felt other men regarded as gorgeous--would leave him if he did not sexually satisfy. Now this was a classic situation where two people drew different conclusions from the same situation. Anecdotally, when I now prescribe Viagra I tell my male patients to go home and reassure their wives. The men are frequently quite perplexed when I point this out but surprised when they find out that their wife was anxious about their sexual allure.

Now what seems to have become apparent to me in my years of practice, is that human thinking tends to be a mix of first and second order communication. While both sexes are capable of both, men in general seem to operate more on a first order basis while women on a second order basis.

Now second order communication has both its benefits and its drawbacks, and these will be dependant on the culture of the recipient of information. Now, if a woman is obsessed with sexual politics she is going there is going to be a very wide variety of "signals" which she is going to interpret in sexuo-political way. More importantly, prejudices of any kind have a profound impact on second order thinking, since information is interpreted in context of the prejudice.

Where second order thinking assumes a dangerous dimension is when the second order thinker asserts that their interpretation is objective and not subjective.

A perfect example of this second order thinking is expressed by Clio in my exchange with her. Clio consistently imputes to me opinions which I do not hold. Now I can see how she could interpret my comments in such a way, but I would ask the reader to go over our little exchange and see if I explicitly make any of the claims she imputes to me.

For example:

Here’s a snippet of what you said to me in your last comment:
(The Social Pathologist)Now a sane and rational man would look at the facts in toto with due regard to each of them and come to the conclusion that this woman was grossly irresponsible in her behaviour. She did not deserve anyone’s sympathy or support. Yet your interpretation of the facts would nullify pertinent features because the conclusions would be “distasteful”.

(Clio) This is the comment to which I was responding when I took your words “personally” and argued in support of my own detachment. It certainly implies that I had been irrational and unreasonable.

It logically implied nothing of the sort, yet Clio perceived it to. Now it could also mean that a sane and rational woman would look at the facts differently. It does not logically follow that a different opinion is necessarily the opinion of an an insane or irrational person. Now it is possible that my writing was ambiguous, but if there was any lack of clarity on my part I suppose the appropriate thing would have been to seek clarification. I am quite capable of stating that women are idiots(even though I don't believe it) or utter other disagreeable comments if the situation arises. The point here is that Clio attributed sentiments to me which I did not posses and then proceeded to vigourously assert that I possessed them. Interestingly she self-identified with her position, perceiving an rebuttal to the subject at hand as an injury to her self.

This is the typical Men are from Mars, Women from Venus, stuff and quite frequently both the source of both mirth and marital misery. A fair portion of my time is spent counselling couples who are in marital strife because of the differences in their perceptions of their marriage.

Now this type of thinking assumes dangerous implications when it comes to sexual harassment (and rape) Suppose a man makes an ambiguous comment which is interpreted as an unwanted sexual advance by a woman. Now the man may have meant one thing but it has been interpreted as another. Whom do the courts believe; the woman who has "experienced" sexual harassment, or the man who has not intentionally offended? A man is dead in the water if his legal system is feminist prejudiced.

The point here is that we as a society need to recognise that men and women both think and perceive differently and take account of it. This does not mean that one is superior than the other. In fact, both forms of thinking have both the benefits and drawbacks, the point is however, that non-recognition of this fact does an injustice to both sexes and is a source of much male female grief.

Here is a LINK to a video by Deborah Tannen, a linguist who has studied how men and women miscommunicate. It's well worth the view.

Further proof that masculinity and femininity are not social constructs; they are innate.







13 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

I'm curious to find out what blog platform you're working with?
I'm having some small security problems with my latest website and I'd
like to find something more secure. Do you have any suggestions?


my webpage kostenlos spiele spielen
my web page: internetradio

Anonymous said...

Ι visited multiple siteѕ еxcept the auԁiо fеature for audіο songѕ exіѕting at this wеbsіte iѕ really
fаbulouѕ.

Alѕo ѵisit my homepаge web page

Anonymous said...

But the the main thing is a lot of your personal data is out there whether it's health information, bank card details or even as the Albuquerque mishap shows courtroom files. I even find myself backing away from recommending other resources which, in the past, I would have shared willingly. Hometown Retired households are comprised of retirees, two-thirds of whom are over 65; nonetheless, don't assume that these
people don't do much more than hang around the house and watch TV all day. 99 Mac Mini only ships with 1GB of RAM. Cons. Originally established as a sanctuary for the Nilgiri Tahr, the 'The Eravikulam National Park' has now turned into a highly popular tourist spot. We relate to it like it's the truth.

In fact the publicly owned Ecopetrol has seen an immense
FDI surge in the past few years and in spite of being overvalued to some, the stock still
is a good bet due to the growth potential it has.
a far cry: a long way from. Therefore, you cannot afford to miss this incredible shooter game involving a series of killings.


Here is my weblog www.imagiscape.ca/wiki/tiki-index.php?page=UserPagedewaynedw

Anonymous said...

Moreover, over the internet there are 2 main versions of this game that is the RA deluxe with
10 pay lines and the classic RA with 9 pay lines.
However, playing it online has now increased your chances of winning.
This is your other tank in Warhammer online, special ability is buffs.


Stop by my page - Visit Website

Anonymous said...

Usually, a brand new website takes about six months to one year to appear in the
SERPs of Google, assuming the service provider is worth their salt.
Spend some time to design a good-looking 404 page,
site offline page, etc. Content, keywords and link building
are some of the factors using which Search Engine Optimization
services are taken care of. While you’re at it, remove all or fix 404 errors.
SEO must be implemented by following a step by step process.
Search engines are getting smarter at detecting sites that are spamming keywords or made
solely for the purpose of advertising. Some SEO firms focus on
content spinning and submitting articles. Content writing for websites is
not as simple as typing out a predetermined amount of words,
if you wish people to view the content. It focuses on networking and impeccable website maintenance.
Over the years, web promotion has made a mark in the industry
and has helped numerous entrepreneurs to build large business
return through web. Those who work on introduced SEO power suite, they choose best SEO tools among various tools available in the market.
If the comments are created for solely promotional purposes,
they will probably get deleted. Their success is based on how many sales and customers you
bring. Immediately the word free caught my eye.
Create a general, high-level category in which
you want to manage all phrases'for example 'global,' 'online,' 'channel,' and so on. It has been designed especially for business purposes and it holds biggest importance for your B2B online marketing strategy. With most visitors noting the first 3-5 web links of the first page, further sustained SEO efforts bring the company web link to that web positioning high up as much as possible. You will not even get to a 1 or 2 until Google has fully crawled your website or blog enough to give it a ranking. First of all a market survey is done by them as to know the competitors analysis. November 2012.

Review my blog - www.backlinkbasis.com

Anonymous said...

While it is one thing to have a social media profile on an online community like Deviant - ART, it is a whole other thing entirely to have fitted it with an effective SEO strategy.

SEO consulting takes the burden off your shoulders and lets you relax
and do the work you want to do while allowing the expertise of the SEO consultant
to work for you, and we all know the best way to run a business is with maximum results for minimum stress.

The more doors you have the more chances of people finding it.
The only thing that cannot be "fixed" later is your blog and
post titles. Since Google organic rank can bring in thousands
of potential customers, search engine position service firms have made a business of
promising high positions in search engine results pages.
Search engines are getting smarter at detecting sites that are spamming keywords
or made solely for the purpose of advertising. Some SEO firms focus on content spinning and submitting articles.
This means that they follow only the steps given to
them by Google and other major search engines. The businesses
have understood the need to take SEO services for
attaining good search engine placement. Numerous SEO services over competitive price for
outsourcing your site online, but, would it be best to hire
the locals if the nature of your business limits to your local as well.
So, most move slowly when deciding on who becomes the company's SEO. If your website deals with certain products or services, then conduct a proper research on these and then form your SEO content. Let us assume that at this point you have 6 keywords. Regardless of whether you like it, love it, or hate it, social media has become a major player in the SEO world, and it is a costly mistake to ignore it. This was the beginning of the thought process for my new business. G) SEO basics -Image 6: Open Google. Today, it is necessary that you scout the market for the best SEO Host that can help you achieve this. However with passing time the complexity in this field has increased and performing an SEO task is not a simple thing to do. You need the keyword and phrase in both title and description. Addition and updation of fresh content always leads to arrival of increased traffic to your websites.

Feel free to visit my homepage: www.linkstatistics.orgmail.bankrottblog.de
my site > Serena

Anonymous said...

As we all know, looks can be deceiving, so I decided
to try out the question tool for myself. If you encourage your visitors to write their
original reviews about your products instead of coping reviews from competitive websites to show you have circulation and satisfied customers, your website is more
likely to earn higher ranking in the major search engines.
The tools include efficient internet marketing,
proper usage of keywords, flawless content and creating social media
buttons. SEO (search engine optimization) and keyword
density are terms that scare many a writer who want to write for the
internet. SEO must be implemented by following a step by step process.
If the conversion is higher with a certain keyword or
a particular set of keywords, then the SEO vendor can focus
on the same keyword to get it ranked high in all the search engines.

They make their strategy according to the audience their client is targeting.
Content writing for websites is not as simple as typing out a predetermined amount
of words, if you wish people to view the content. Online research is required to determine the
packages and SEO Company. Over the years, web promotion has made a mark in the industry and has helped numerous entrepreneurs
to build large business return through web. The final way that you can
use your Deviant - ART profile for SEO purposes is by being an
active member of the community ' watch the work of others (especially if they are related to your business), encourage others to watch your work, comment on work, list other users as your friends. The growth management of small business can be accomplished with SEO as an integral part of your overall Internet marketing strategy. Moving your hosting to a nearby country such as Canada or an offshore Caribbean host may provide the same latency times, but reduce the risk of having your website brought down by a mistake. Regardless of whether you like it, love it, or hate it, social media has become a major player in the SEO world, and it is a costly mistake to ignore it. Once you find the right and affordable SEO Company, it is essential to talk about your business objectives, target customers and future goals with the professionals to help them develop their strategies accordingly. It has been designed especially for business purposes and it holds biggest importance for your B2B online marketing strategy. With most visitors noting the first 3-5 web links of the first page, further sustained SEO efforts bring the company web link to that web positioning high up as much as possible. A person can find all sorts of products available at various prices on the internet. And make the work flow smoothly, using good grammar at all times. Never post a half edited article, and never settle for less than your best.

Look into my blog post: http://www.breakernyc.com

Anonymous said...

7 WCLH ( Fоrmаt: Collegе Radio
Wіlkes Uniνегsіty's radio station plays mostly alternative rock, but Mondays have seemingly always been "Metal Mondays. The broadcasting process is not complicated as all the equipments essential are easily available but with new ideas coming up every day, new requirements rise with new criteria of transmission like Dab Digital Radio and DRM. Even if you have a good two way radio, it isn't baԁ to
have ѕome kind of receіνe only гaԁio
tο get information on.

My ωеb blοg Read More Listed here

Anonymous said...

Wow, awesome blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is magnificent,
let alone the content!

my website - spiele spielen kostenlos

Anonymous said...

Therefore, the characters must sell animal skins in order to get money for buying the weapons.
So even at young ages and relatively low levels of the sport, goalies will have their helmets designed with various colors, prints and patterns, shapes
or designs, and more. Official Picture of President Reagan by
the Executive Office of the Presidency used under Public Domain.

So, in conclusion, removing the headphones from your
MP3 player is not bad, provided you don't yank too hard on the cord. Overall I'll say the game isn't that re playable. Originally established as a sanctuary for the Nilgiri Tahr, the 'The
Eravikulam National Park' has now turned into a highly popular tourist spot. In 2005, the QI Group acquired a UK-based independent telecommunications provider with a strong background in providing advanced communications solutions and technology in the United Kingdom. Most visitors on a trip to Munnar invariably end up at the Tata Tea Museum and gain some delightful insights into the process of tea making. a far cry: a long way from. There is a rarely discussed addiction that can be as enslaving as drugs and as devastating to self-respect, self-confidence and healthy functioning as alcoholism.

Feel free to surf to my page http://www.hotelmalioboro.com/node/25804

Anonymous said...

Hold down an app for a second, and start turning off all the apps that you aren't using by pressing the "minus" button. As you lift out the screen you'll see it is still attached via a
ribbon cable. Although, sound card is integrated device, it functions similar to brightness
of the screen when talking about power consumption.

Take a look at my web page ... radiosender - wiki.shsh.ylc.edu.tw